I wasn’t going to blog about Terri Schiavo. Actually, if you browse through the Dynamobuzz archives, there are other topics that I haven’t really touched on, such as gay marriage or abortion. But then I saw Jim at Parkway Rest Stop take a strong stand as did Enlighten-NewJersey. Mike at Sluggo Needs a Nap also laid out his position as did Patrick at Jerseystyle, so I decided to add mine.
As I said yesterday, I spoke to my mother who happens to be a nurse. I know she has seen too many cases of people truly on life support who are still getting thousands of dollars of medical tests and treatments for basically no good reason, and she has shaken her head in despair saying that it’s no way to live. I was surprised that she was only lukewarm in support of the husband in this case. She thinks he may have other motives, but the law is that the husband has the right to make this decision. But my mother was very adamant that Schiavo is not brain dead or on life support, she’s basically a severely handicapped person being fed through a tube. And my mom thinks they should at least give her water. Her death would be postponed for several more days or weeks, but it would be a better way to die than by dehydration.
I wish that Schiavo’s husband would just sign over the custodial rights of Terri to her parents and then part ways. And from what I’ve read there is more than enough to question the original diagnosis and justify a new hearing. But that’s not going to happen. Schiavo is going to be slowly killed by dehydration. Basically, there’s no happy ending to this story.
Maybe the biggest thing that bothers me is that there are people who may actually be celebrating when Schiavo dies. Peggy Noonan touched on this in today’s Wall Street Journal, “In Love With Death, The bizarre passion of the pull-the-tube people“. There is a pretty frightening pro-euthanisia group out there that is slowly gaining acceptability. Dr. Kevorkian was probably the poster child for this movement, this attitude that once life isn’t “worth living” you have a right to end that life. And there is one state so far, Oregon, where assisted suicide is legal.
And, please, I’m not saying everyone who supports Schiavo’s death is in this camp. I’m sure many are like my mother, torn between the choices. Just the same, it’s not just “the religious kooks” who supported the efforts to grant federal jurisdiction to this case. Iowa Democrat Tom Harkin has been a supporter of handicapped rights for his entire career, and he looks at Mrs. Schiavo and sees a disabled lady about to be starved to death. NY Democrat Jose Serrano felt that when the situation is not crystal clear, you should err on the side that keeps her alive. Other liberal democrats who supported the measure in Congress included Carrie Meek, Elijah Cummings, Stephanie Herseth, Chakah Fatah, Jesse Jackson Jr and Albert Wynn. And Bob Novak commented that Ralph Nader told him it was “..illegal to starve a dog to death but it was being done to Terri Schiavo.”
The next fights will arise when this “pro-death” movement spreads to other disabilities, like children born with severe handicaps or senior citizens whose health has deteriorated to the point where they are incapacitated. And unless our lawmakers move fast to clear up the law, it will be in the hands of unaccountable, unelected judges and lawyers like the thoroughly creepy Geoffrey Feiger who will be setting the law.