I haven’t blogged much about the immigration debate, but tonight’s speech by the president gave me some motivation. I noticed when I hosted the Carnival of the NJ Bloggers a few weeks back that immigration was a popular topic.
I’m generally a hawk on immigration, but I don’t know what to do with all illegals already here, estimated at about 12 million. I think they would all get hearings if the government tried to deport them, and that would tie up the court system for years. I don’t know the solution, but giving them preference for residency and citizenship is wrong.
I don’t know how many of you know immigrants who are legally trying to gain residency and citizenship. I’ve known many over the years, and there’s three that I’m most familiar with. Two were co-workers, one a woman who was a business manager from England and another woman, an engineer from Columbia, who went to college here in the US. The third is a member of my church, a man from Senegal, who has been trying for five years to get his son into this country. All three have been following the rules, spending thousands of dollars on attorneys, taking time off from work for interviews and meetings, meticulously making sure their visas were always current. Immigration law is a confusing mess, and it seems like these people I know are constantly being given the runaround. Yet they persist, not by waving signs and making demands but by trying twice as hard to make sure they have dotted the i’s and crossed all the t’s.
I am embarrased as an American to see these people I know, people following the rules, being given the runaround while our government is talking about giving amnesty to millions of illegal aliens. They entered the country illegally, they are working illegally, many being paid in cash to avoid taxes, many are driving illegally. How many laws do you have to break before we can conclude that perhaps they don’t have respect for our system?? And those demonstrations, with thousands of uninvited illegals making demands on us most likely turned off many Americans who were undecided.
Are we a nation of immigrants?? Of course we are, but legal immigrants. My father came here from Puerto Rico in the 1950’s. My mother was born here, but her parents came from Austria right after WWI. And even with all the immigration runaround, hundreds of thousands come here every year to legally work and many become residents and eventually citizens.
And our economy will do just fine without all the illegals. The “jobs Americans won’t do” line is a joke. In most cases, employers use illegals because they’re cheap. In Cincinnati they have ben cracking down on illegals and found that contractors are shipping then into the area and housing them and paying them half the average wage for legal workers. Imagine the uproar if Jon Corzine said, “We can’t find enough school teachers at $20,000 a year, so we’re going to import them from India and the Phillipines”.
Tightening the borders and cracking down on employers should be the strategy, not amnesty for millions of lawbreakers. Andy McCarthy at National Review summarized it best: “We should make it harder for illegals to get in, and be clear to those already here that staying is going to be more unpleasant – because employers are going to be prosecuted, immigrants who commit state and federal crimes are going to be jailed then deported, and all our sparse processing resources are going to be dedicated to those who are following the existing rules for legal immigration.”